A Big “Doh” to the Pro-Tax Community

From BusinessWeek:

When Julie Abel goes grocery shopping each week, she drives more than 25 miles to Georgia to avoid paying the nation’s highest average tax on food: 8.4 percent in Tennessee.

“If you can save $5 it is worth driving down the road,” Abel said after traveling from her rural home in Hamilton County, which collects 2.22 percent sales tax on food on top of the 6 percent for the state. Georgia does not tax food sales.

Abel is not alone in her frustration. Rep. Michael Kernell, D-Memphis, said he regularly hears complaints about the state’s almost 60-year-old food tax and he predicted it would change.

“A lot of people can’t believe it,” he said. “People are leaving the state to buy groceries.”

As a strong advocate for lower taxes and having worked this particular issue in Tennessee, Alabama, and Georgia, I am in disbelief that anyone would find this shocking or even newsworthy. Of course people wish to pay less for the same product — taxes or no taxes. And people are pretty opposed to taxation, too — especially in the heart of the south.

Perhaps Tennessee is starting to get what folks in Alabama have known, though:

Chris Daly, chairman of Tennesseans for Fair Taxation, wants to end the state’s tax on food because he said it victimizes low and middle income people.

I used those arguments again and again during the Alabama tax debacle, where we (rich and poor alike) took the Republican governor’s proposal for the largest tax increase in state history and shoved it up his [you know what]. I’ve spent a lot of time canvassing the streets in Birmingham’s most crime-ridden neighborhoods and their word is typically the same as in lily-white agricultural areas and smaller towns: We can no longer allow these outrageous taxes.

Perhaps others in the south are now getting it, too. I’ve met Kimble Forester of Alabama ARISE on several occasions, and we agree upon and are allied on many civil liberties and justice-related issues — but not typically on taxation. From the article:

Another report by Tennesseans for Fair Taxation shows average sales taxes on food in states that border Tennessee range from no tax in Kentucky to 8 percent in both Alabama and Arkansas.

In Alabama, a spokesman for Montgomery-based Alabama Arise, an advocacy group for the poor, said there is an ongoing effort to eliminate or at least reduce the tax on food.

“We are taxing the poor on the necessities of life and that is something most states avoid. But we are doing it with pride,” said Alabama Arise director Kimble Forrister.

Welcome aboard, Kimble. Maybe we can now work together to get rid of a very wide range of oppressive taxation.

Stephen Gordon

I like tasteful cigars, private property, American whiskey, fast cars, hot women, pre-bailout Jeeps, fine dining, worthwhile literature, low taxes, original music, personal privacy and self-defense rights -- but not necessarily in this order.

  1. Last time I checked, Tennessee had the highest sales taxes of anywhere in the whole country — even higher than California. I was shocked earlier this fall to pay a whopping 9.75% total sales tax in Nashville, for instance. On FOOD.

  2. Well let’s do away with all taxes. Buth then I guess we’ll have to do away with police services, firemen, schools, roads, parks, and oh yeah, an all of the armed forces.
    You can’t have your cake and eat it too. Morons.

  3. p.s. the woman who drove 25 miles to save $5. How much did she spend on gas, cuz I’m pretty sure she wasn’t driving a hybrid. Morons.

  4. David,
    You are the moron.

    I can certainly afford the tax on a NECESSITY, but the average & the poor pay a HIGHER % of their income on something that is not a luxury.

    As a resident of Pennsylvania ” The land of taxes ” the one good thing I can say is that we do not tax food.

    No one is suggesting doing away with ALL taxes.

    What is being suggested is that NECESSITIES like FOOD not be taxed.

    Got it moron ?

  5. Names will not get anything done about it. has anyone contacted the congressmen or local politicians about this? perhaps they need to look to the general populace for the needs OF the general populace… I feel horrible about the fact that it has come down to taxing FOOD for chrissake. why not just legalize drugs and tax THAT? hrm…

  6. There’s kind of a seesaw effect here.

    The highest sales taxes tend to be in states like Tennessee and Alabama that are restrained from taxing in other ways. Alabama property taxes are the lowest in the nation, and the burden of its income tax falls mainly on the poor, since the well to do can deduct what they pay on their federal tax and since the income at which tax is charged in Alabama is very low. Tennessee, of course, has no income tax. When the wealthy build walls around themselves to keep from being taxed, the burden is inevitably placed on the poor, and politicians run around trying to squeeze blood out of turnips with sales taxes, wheel taxes and the like.